We can do better at the ballot box

The first-past-the-post (FPTP) system is neither fair to the parties nor voters

Editor, The Times:

I am disappointed that a poll conducted by Kamloops-Thompson-Cariboo Conservative MP Cathy McLeod showed a majority of voters do not want to change our electoral system and, that if the government were to propose a new system, the majority of voters would like to put it to a referendum.

At the expense of sounding patronizing, I suggest many of these voters who want to continue with the current system have not taken time to study its limitations.

Also, a referendum would be an inappropriate waste of money.

We have representatives in Parliament to introduce appropriate legislation — and the subject of electoral reform has been reviewed numerous times over the years.

The first-past-the-post (FPTP), or single-member plurality (SMP) system as it is officially called, is neither fair to the parties nor voters.

In the 2015 federal election, the Bloc Quebecois won 10 seats with 4.7 per cent of total votes cast in the country, while the Green party won only one seat with 3.4 per cent of  votes cast.

A party can get, say, 10 per cent of total votes cast across the country and yet not have a single seat in Parliament. In other words, votes received by a party do not reflect that party’s seats in Parliament.

In the 2015 federal election, for example, the Liberals won every seat across the four Atlantic provinces, even though 37 per cent of the region’s voters voted for other parties.

In the FPTP system, votes are also wasted.

Since a candidate only needs one more vote than his or her opponents, the winner’s votes beyond that number are wasted.

A voter may have a second preference of which he or she is not asked.

Proportional representation (PR) tries to minimize these anomalies.

There are different PR systems.

Some appear complex at first sight and require larger ridings with multiple seats. Also, multiple vote counts are often needed to appropriately redistribute the ballots  if there is no immediate winner.

All this was time-consuming before the computer era, but this is no longer the case.

One potential disadvantage of some PR systems, with enlarged ridings with multiple seats, is the geographic location of elected representative may not be as close to voters’ home as in the current system of small ridings with one seat.

It may be possible to compromise on this and other potential issues to develop a system suitable for Canada, with its uniquely large area and sparsely distributed population.

Let us look at our current electoral system closely.

We can do better.

Max Zahir

 

Kamloops, B.C.

 

 

Just Posted

Moose Hide campaign sees annual growth

“It was awesome—from last year to this year it was amazing,” said co-organizer Cindy Wilgosh

Road conditions for Feb. 21

Electrical maintenance planned on Highway 5

B.C. Interior free from measles

Vancouver measles outbreak hasn’t spread to the B.C. Interior

B.C. BUDGET: Surplus $374 million after bailouts of BC Hydro, ICBC

Growth projected stronger in 2020, Finance Minister Carole James says

Back in Time

Historical Perspective

New report calls for regulated heroin sales to curb B.C.’s overdose problem

B.C. Centre on Substance Use points to organized crime and money-laundering as contributing factors

Millennial men least likely to have a family doctor: Statistics Canada

Report found more women have primary care physicians, compared with men

70% of Canadians agree with mandatory vaccines for children: poll

The debate for pro and anti vaccinations has heated up after a measles outbreak in Vancouver

VIDEO: Woman, off-duty cop in serious condition after stabbing outside B.C. elementary school

The officer was interceding in an alleged assault when he and the woman were stabbed

‘A little baloney’ in PM’s claim about solicitor-client privilege on SNC-Lavalin

The Conservatives and NDP want Trudeau to waive that privilege so Wilson-Raybould can offer her side of the story

Proposed edible pot rules are wasteful, would leave products tasteless: critics

When Canada legalized weed last fall, it only allowed fresh or dried bud, oil, plants and seeds

Samsung folding phone is different – but also almost $2,000

But most analysts see a limited market for foldable-screen phones

Most Read