Ontario’s Climate Action Plan undermines case for carbon pricing

Putting a price on CO2 production is the best way to reduce emissions but only if regulations and subsidies are eliminated

VANCOUVER, B.C. and CALGARY, Alta. / Troy Media/ – Proponents of carbon taxes and cap-and-trade schemes often defend their position on the grounds that simply attaching a “price” to carbon is the most economically efficient way to reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHGs). They argue it is less economically damaging to simply price pollution and let the market decide how emissions can be most cheaply reduced compared to a regulatory approach mandating specific emissions reductions.

And this argument is correct – in an economics textbook at least. In the real world, introducing a carbon pricing plan does not eliminate an apparently insatiable desire of governments to micromanage the economy in the name of environmental protection. Instead of carbon pricing replacing regulations, what we see is governments adding additional subsidies and regulations at the same time.

This is exactly what seems to be happening in Ontario. Recent news stories report Ontario is preparing to unveil a sweeping Climate Change Action Plan that would move Ontario’s energy markets further in the direction of central planning. The plan is reported to include a new slate of subsidies and command-and-control style regulations that would come atop the government’s recently announced cap-and-trade scheme. This combination would leave Ontario’s economy even more over-regulated and over-taxed.

Ontario’s government recently defended its new cap-and-trade plan by noting there is a “broad consensus that carbon pricing is the best tool for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.” This is, again, in theory correct. But the reason carbon pricing is theoretically the best way to reduce emissions is that it should allow governments to eliminate the distortive regulations and subsidies they might otherwise use to reduce emissions.

But that’s not happening in Ontario. Instead, as the reporting on the government’s Climate Change Action Plan makes clear, the Wynne government is committed to adding another layer of regulation and subsidies on top of the new cap-and-trade plan.

Here are just a few examples. The climate change plan is reported to include $285 million in subsidies to encourage people to buy electric cars. The plan is also reported to call for new lower-carbon fuel standards for transportation fuels. In addition to its new subsidies and regulations, the plan apparently sets specific targets for transforming the province’s automobile fleet to the point that 12 per cent of all vehicles sold in 2025 will be electric vehicles.

These rules, subsidies, and specific targets represent precisely the type of economic micromanagement that carbon pricing is meant to eliminate the need for. The whole concept of emissions pricing is that, after setting the appropriate market price for carbon, there’s no need for central planners to fuss over what percentage of cars are fuelled by electricity. Those sorts of details are meant to be sorted out by price signals and the market.

But Ontario’s government is apparently unwilling to abide by the central economic theory behind carbon pricing and seems determined to press ahead with intrusive economic interventions. Ontario will wind up with higher taxes and more regulation and more distortive subsidies, a dangerous combination for the provincial economy.

In theory, replacing most environmental regulations aimed at reducing greenhouse gases with an economy-wide carbon tax could make the economy more efficient. In reality, governments have proven unwilling to stop meddling in the economy after introducing carbon pricing and continue to enact new rules dictating what goods and services the economy should produce and how it ought to produce them. That’s what’s happening in Ontario, and the economic outcomes aren’t likely to be pretty.


– Ben Eisen is associate director of provincial prosperity studies and Kenneth P. Green is senior director of natural resource studies with the Fraser Institute.



Just Posted

Community of Vavenby: weekly news update

Railroad tracks being replaced from Clearwater to Blue River

Lambing in full swing at Aveley Sheep Ranch

Spring is here and this may be most obvious at Aveley Heritage… Continue reading

RCMP looking for grain haulers dumping grain on roadside pull-outs

Illegal practice happening on Highway 5 between Valemount and Avola

Personal Development Weekend Retreat coming up

By K.A. Pendergast Have you ever been stressed? I am sure most… Continue reading

MayDay Parade Theme is “Clearwater Life”

Parade takes place May 18 and starts at Capostinsky Park

What’s age got to do with it? B.C. couple with 45-year gap talks happy marriage

An Armstrong couple that has 45-year age gap began turning heads after being featured on show Extreme Love.

B.C. men challenge constitutionality of Canada’s secret no-fly list

Parvkar Singh Dulai says he received a “denial of boarding” notification under the no-fly program last May 17

Murder on B.C. property didn’t need to be disclosed before sale, court rules

Buyer had tried to break contract after learning a man with ties to crime had been murdered there

B.C.’s largest Vaisakhi festival target of threatening Facebook post: Surrey RCMP

Police say they are investigating the posts on Facebook, after local MLA forwarded screenshots

Pug life: B.C. town boasts waggish list of dog names

Freedom-of-information request lists most ‘pupular’ dog names registered in White Rock

VIDEO: Fish farming company launches $30-million vessel to treat salmon for sea lice in B.C. waters

Freshwater treatment an improvement but fish farms should be removed from sea, says conservationist

Singh says childhood abuse steeled him for scrutiny and stress of politics

He recounts the assaults for the first time in his book Love & Courage

Despite five extra weeks’ parental leave in Canada, dads still face stigma: survey

One reason people said dads don’t need leave is because they can just bond with their kids at weekend

Vintage bottles, magic cards, a 1969 Playboy: Quirky items found in historic B.C. buildings

Crews set aside some of the funkier pieces emerging from the construction rubble

Most Read